52° and Fog
Preserving the Past, One Guest at a Time: The Marshall House
Built in 1913, the James G. Marshall House stands as a testament to the enduring legacy of Niagara Falls’ historic architecture and the people who have called it home. Thanks to decades of dedicated preservation, this grand residence has transformed into a meaningful destination for both history lovers and travelers from around the world.
The home was first lovingly restored between 1994 and 2004 by preservation champions Tom and Louise Yots, who converted it into a traditional bed and breakfast and secured its listing on the National Register of Historic Places. Their work laid the foundation for what would become a deeply personal and historically rich journey.
In January 2022, Matt and Cherrish Beals became the newest stewards of the Marshall House. Initially intending to maintain the home as a whole-house vacation rental, everything changed with a surprising discovery: a letter from James G. Marshall’s great-granddaughter, Ellen, found in a steam trunk in the attic. Alongside the letter was what Ellen believed to be her grandmother’s wedding dress—revealed to actually be her great-grandmother’s gown from 1898.
Through a connection facilitated by Tom Yots, Cherrish reached out to Ellen, and a unique bond was formed. The Marshall House soon became more than just a place to stay—it became a living tribute to the Marshall family’s history.
Today, Matt and Cherrish proudly operate the Marshall House once again as a bed and breakfast, welcoming guests from across the globe. With the help of Fahim and Seema Mojawalla of Island Ship Center, they have curated a small museum within the home featuring artifacts donated by the Marshall family descendants. Highlights include the lovingly restored wedding dress, James G. Marshall’s personal copy of a proposal to designate Navy Island as the home of the United Nations, and memorabilia from Old Fort Niagara, where Mr. Marshall was a founding director of the Old Fort Niagara Association.
The Marshall House is also a vibrant part of the local community. It hosts musicians during the Park Place Porchfest, welcomes international high school exchange students, and has served as a set for film and documentary projects. Matt and Cherrish embrace their role not only as hosts but as ambassadors of local history, committed to continuing the legacy of the Marshall family.
We are proud to honor The Marshall House for their exceptional Residential Project. Matt and Cherrish have embraced their role as stewards of this historic 1913 home, thoughtfully maintaining its legacy and sharing its rich history with the community and visitors alike.
“Matt and Cherrish are not only fine stewards of the Marshall House, but they are upstanding, dedicated community members of Niagara Falls. The passion and dedication they bring to making the Falls a better place is truly inspiring. I’m so proud of you two!” Emily Jarnot, Preservation Planner, Preservation Buffalo Niagara
