In depth with Mayor Restaino

Image

A temporary roof at 1092 Main St.

There’s been a lot going on in Niagara Falls government news in recent weeks, Mayor Robert Restaino still can be mercurial, and it would be OK if he was testy.

The Express expected some reason for cancellation. Who schedules a press interview, when he doesn’t like the press, for 4 p.m. on a Friday?

Instead, he walked into the city hall conference room 5 minutes early, for the 8th time in 2026 and apologized for being under the weather. For every meeting but one, he was early and the time he was late he was on the phone with James Heastie, speaker of the State Assembly.

He is recovering from pneumonia but didn’t miss work. Most of the questions in what follows were submitted by people who don’t like him. A couple came from sycophants. Even fewer came from supporters. If you don't financially contribute to Niagara Express, which is a reader-supported, I hope you will reconsider. I have worked hard to avoid a paywall but just shelled out $700 for a new laptop. You can contribute through the Niagara Express website or by contacting the editor but this is a passion project created for a love of journalism and Niagara Falls, not profit.

What follows are questions in italics. Answers are mostly paraphrased but when in quotes are exact. I tried and failed to record the interview.

Why not face he public

A resident asked why you won’t appear in public and take question from residents.They also wanted to know why requested documents are so hard to be released. I know how I might answer, but I said I would ask, so what do you say?

“What would be the forum for that? I don’t know. I am endlessly answering resident questions. Some come to me while I am shopping, eating dinner, walking in the park. I am endlessly approached.”

Every department answers records requests weaved in with regular work. We work as quickly as we can and also ensure to remove information that needs to remain private.

How about Pine Avenue?

What’s the update on the city market? How about Save-a-Lot?

There is nothing new about the empty grocery. The market development team continues to meet with stakeholders. The most recent result is to move the market even closer to Pine Avenue. The most recent input came from folks at the Cristoforo Colombo Society.

Is he going to run?

Have you decided to run for reelection?

“I am evaluating a couple of different things. It is close.”

So if you were leaning for running, or against, how would you answer?”

I can’t really say.

About the Rapids

I spent an hour Thursday watching a Jesse Gooch press conference. He is threatening legal action. Is it sound and fury signifying nothing? Does his proposed lawsuit stand a chance?

“I don’t know what lawsuit. I know there is a lot of misinformation woven into the things he says. The fact of the matter is he never discusses his March 2 phone call with me.”

The mayor said he did not record the call but now wishes he had. Gooch explained the reasoning for some of what was included in his application and why it was presented the way it was.

The Mayor also said the new owners of the theater, Chris Ring and Dale Segal, did a walk through on Friday in anticipation of interior work and that state taxpayer funded roof work will be completed before winter.

What about Jalin and Jayla?

There were protestors outside city hall on Wednesday demanding justice for Jalin and Jayla. Why didn’t you come out and talk to them?

“I was working through my schedule. Our police department continues to work on the case. From the most experienced officer to the least experienced officer, everyone goes to bed and wakes up thinking about that case.

“We have provided resources to the families and also made available information. It is less than accurate to say there has been no communication. It is a slow moving investigation.”

The mayor noted the biggest thing hampering the investigation is the fact so few witnesses are willing to come forward. It’s the reason the city just launched an anonymous tip line, hoping to close the gap and solve the case.

What about body cameras?

Talk to me a bit about how body cameras have changed police work. In recent weeks we’ve had at least 3 police reports involving officers on anti violence patrol recognize someone wanted on a warrant, exit their car, have the suspect run and take them into custody after a chase. In every instance the last line on the report is “the entire incident was recorded by this officer’s body camera.”

“I told the department since I came here that body cameras should not be something you are afraid of. Any time, in some way, the use of force is questioned, the first thing we ask is ‘do you have the body cam footage?’ It gives a good view of what happened.”

The mayor said there have been 3 instances involving discharge of a weapon since he has been mayor where that video explained exactly what happened. One of them was less than 30 seconds and ended in the death of a civilian.

About that residency requirement

Speak to me about the residency requirement. Would you consider waiving it in order to make recruiting employees easier?

The mayor said while it is a consideration, it is not an easy discussion because residents contribute to property taxes which pay benefits and salaries.

Why don’t you attend council work sessions?

I know it is not required, but if you could attend council work sessions would it reduce chaos and improve council meetings?

“No because I have attended some and it is still chaotic. What would help is a dialogue so we can gather information and answer questions. In the early days (of his administration) that happened with council members. Funneling everything through the chairperson is absurd. How much do they want to work? Call me on the weekend. Call me at night.”

The mayor said when council members are willing to reach out and have actual conversations, preferably in person, rather than relying on text messages and emails it becomes easier to get things done.

He said it is not a lack of hard work or availability. He came into the meeting with the Express apologizing because he is getting over pneumonia. He didn’t miss any work. On Veteran’s Day, he went to the ceremony at Hyde Park and then left to go to the office.

How are casino negotiations?

Speak to me about the state of casino negotiations.

Things are in limbo at the state level. The Seneca Nation released a statement directed to the host communities. That is at least a starting point. The mayor also pointed out the city deals directly with the Senecas on some issues, for example, providing a police detective assigned to the casino under a contract.

Disabled vets want a tax exemption

A veteran asked about a property tax exemption for disabled vets. How do you feel about that? Many communities have passed it.

“I don’t know the dollar amounts but I expect to have a resolution in front of the council before year end.”

Where is the DRI money? It’s been 7 years.

$10 million in Downtown Revitalization Initiative money was promised by the state in 2019. What is the status of projects 7 years later?

Most of that funding was with Blue Cardinal Development until 2024. Since Blue Cardinal left, the city is now moving forward with the streetscape and other things on Main Street. Construction will begin early next year.

What about the Heritage Area?

The Heritage Area did not move forward with the church at Main and Lockport. What’s next?

“What happened is we had different extensions granted and then we had other inquiries on the property. At some point to avoid repeating past performance, we needed to get a commitment or move on.”

(Editor’s note: The Heritage Area’s leadership told the Express last month it decided not to move forward with the project. Other sources told the Express that while some employees of the Heritage area were comfortable moving forward, the executive director and board were uncomfortable because of the scope of the commitment.)

Suspension Bridge updates

Any updates on other Main Street projects?

All things currently are moving forward. A new inquiry was recently received for a property on Division Street to be a mixed use development including short term rental and commercial space.

Where next on the LDC

Councilmember David Zajac voted no on the Local Development Corporation. What will it take to get a funding commitment to change his mind?

The Mayor questions why Zajac would vote no when the idea of an LDC is to separate the proposed new facility from being a taxpayer obligation. Zajac is seeking state funding to be committed to the city for construction prior to the formation of an LDC which would put a fiscal wall between city taxpayers and Centennial Park.

In the Mayor’s chronology between Fall of 2022 and early 2023, the city council authorized outside counsel to take quiet title to the former park. Court action in State Supreme Court resulted in the city receiving the land and paying $4.2 million to Niagara Falls Redevelopment.

Outside counsel was brought in and included every element requested by the council in the LDC agreement’s third iteration. Going through that whole process and still getting a no vote is a slap in the face.

“To be saying’the biggest obstacle was the acquisition of the land,’ then we get the land and another concern was ‘how do we protect the taxpayer?’ Outside Counsel says ‘an LDC,’ but you aren’t OK protecting the taxpayers. It is illogical.”

Can we sell that land for $4.2 million?

If no funding comes forward, what can we do with that land?

“The ball is in the council’s court. They already turned down the LDC after the council supported the project.”

Skipping the garbage fee increase cost homeowners

Is there anything else you’d like to discuss? With that, the Mayor went to the white board where the tax sale process timeline is still illustrated and drew two circles, one inside the other, representing the pool of people paying the garbage fee.

When the council failed to pass a $2.45 increase in the garbage fee, paid by everyone with a tote, it pushed the $675,000 fee increase into the general fund.

“Now we are looking at an $87 tax increase on a $150,000 house. $17.45 of that is for the garbage fee. I don’t know about you, but which is more in your world? $2.10 or $17.45.”

I'm interested
I disagree with this
This is unverified
Spam
Offensive