Mister B's to reopen

expandA deal is pending that will see Mister B's transition to All In Pizzeria at 2201 Hyde Park Blvd in Niagara Falls.Tracey Drury

Senior Reporter, Buffalo Business FirstJan 13, 2026

A year-old pizzeria is expanding with a move from Youngstown to Niagara Falls.

All In Pizzeria is in the process of buying Mister B’s at 2201 Hyde Park Blvd., where it plans to reopen in late January after ending its lease at 3909 Creek Road in Youngstown.

All In Pizzeria was opened in fall 2024 at the former Grandma D’s by a team of owners that includes Andy Snover, Jeffrey Salhab and Jason Clark, along with Snover's cousin Jim Spence and his wife, Tara.

Contracts are signed, with a deal expected to close by late January, Snover said. Terms were not disclosed.

expandAll In Pizzeria is planning a move from Youngstown to Niagara Falls.All In Pizzeria

Besides offering a dining room and bar, the new space also will allow for third-party delivery, which was difficult in rural Youngstown, where deliveries often took more than two hours.

“One of the things we wanted to do but could not afford was delivery. This (location) falls within the radius of third-party delivery and gives us the ability to continue and be able to deliver to the community,” he said. “The majority of the drivers are coming from the Falls, anyway, so it gives us better ability to grow and expand.”

Mister B’s closed under longtime owner Johnny Martino in summer 2024, with the business transitioning to another operator. Martino, who owns the building, continues to operate Mister M’s House of Food & Drink, which reopened in 2023 at 2939 Hyde Park after moving from Military Road.

Plans for All In Pizzeria call for starting with pick-up and delivery of its standard pizza and wings menu, with an expanded menu and dine-in service to follow along with a liquor license.

“We’re going to be expanding the menu and reaching out to a larger clientele,” Snover said. “We’re going to do fish frys, a beef on weck and we’re debating Reubens, plus we will do some dine-in specials and a nightly special like they previously did at Mister B’s.”

In other restaurant news:

• GolfDojo LLC opened a Southtowns site at 3930 Burke Parkway in Blasdell in late December. The company launched its first site in 2022 at 7350 Transit Road, Buffalo, then added locations at 1154 Niagara Falls Blvd, Suite 102, Tonawanda, and at 1812 Tavern, 5381 Abbott Road in Hamburg. The company offers indoor golf facility with four simulator bays.
• Occasions by Osteria has opened a catering/banquet center at 1841 Whitehaven Blvd. on Grand Island in a former Knights of Columbus Hall. Osteria 166 owner Nick Pitillo is part of a team that invested $1.8 million to convert the hall into an event space.
• The former Brownie’s Sports Bar and Tavern has been sold. The owners of Wonderly Lights of Western New York bought the building at 775 Oliver St., North Tonawanda, in November through 775 BNP LLP, paying owner Lynda Brown $285,000 for the restaurant building and a warehouse building at 110 Ninth Ave. behind the building. Brown and her late husband, Steve, closed Brownie’s in mid-2024 as he battled stage four prostate cancer. The site briefly reopened as Voodoo Child Bar & Lounge. Wonderly owner Scott Franasiak posted on social media he plans to move his outdoor lighting business into the warehouse and is exploring possibilities for the restaurant, including working with a caterer or food truck operator.